On October 17, 2010 it was announced that Like Moths to Flames had been signed to Rise Records and were already working on their first EP. Since the vocalist was familiar with the record company. Two months later, the band released their EP titled Sweet Talker on December 14, 2010. To help support their new music, the band set out with fellow acts Texas in July and A Hero a Fake on the "A Metal Christmas" tour through late 2010. Sometime before their EP was released, drummer Jordan Matz left Like Moths to Flames, and was replaced by Lance Greenfield.

With continuous touring through 2011, the band decided to settle back down and head into the studio to record their first full-length studio album. Right before the band headed to the studio, bassist Aaron Douglas parted ways with the band. The band had Eli Ford (formerly of My Ticket Home) join on guitar and Aaron Evans moved to bass. When We Don't Exist was released on November 8 through Rise Records. In January 2012, the band headed out on the S.I.N. Tour with acts D.R.U.G.S., Hit the Lights and Sparks the Rescue to support.

The band then spent the first half of 2013 headlining the Rise Records tour around the US with supporting acts Crown the Empire, The Color Morale, Palisades and My Ticket Home. The band recorded their second full-length album with Will Putney at (The Machine Shop) in Hoboken, New Jersey and was released July 9, 2013. On May 29, 2013, the band confirmed the new album was called An Eye for an Eye. The album debuted at number 63 on the Billboard 200 top sales. They toured with the Vans Warped Tour over the summer of 2013.

In a Q/A interview with Stheart, Chris Roetter announced the band has been writing new music and intends to release it "soon." While he was very hush hush about what the album is about or the sound of it, he did explain that it is not unfamiliar to the fans. Later on that month, singles were released to appease the fan-base and promote the upcoming album. On Monday, April 6, the band released a standalone release on 7" Vinyl called "The Dream is Dead", featuring two tracks - the A-side being "Bury Your Pain" and the B-side being "What's Done is Done".

On Monday, April 6, the band released a standalone release on 7" Vinyl called "The Dream is Dead", featuring two tracks - the A-side being "Bury Your Pain" and the B-side being "What's Done is Done". The band's third full-length album, The Dying Things We Live For, was announced on 3 September 2015, confirming its release date to be October 23, 2015. Upon release, the album debuted at number 150 on the Billboard 200. Three singles from the album have been released thus far, and we are waiting on more. With sound close to older albums.

On September 8th, 2017, the band released the lead single from the forthcoming album, "Nowhere Left to Sink." They announced that the album would be released on November 3rd, 2017. The music video for "Nowhere Left to Sink" was released exclusively to AltPress on September 26th. They released a promotional single and title track, "Dark Divine" through Loudwire on October 6th. A second promotional single, "Empty the Same" was released on October 13th. A third promotional single, "Shallow Truths for Shallow Minds."